|
|
Post by Dameon on Jul 5, 2004 16:47:16 GMT 11
Exactly what I was thinking, Talisha!
And I think it's the otehr reason Ron hates Harry being so famous and talented and rich and stuff. In case Hermione likes him better!
KSL
|
|
|
|
Post by Rilla on Jul 5, 2004 16:48:05 GMT 11
I agree that dumbledore knew he was innocent too, and in the book it only said he provided evidence that sirius was the potters secret keeper. It doesn't say that he believed sirius guilty. or something. meh.
Ron is just annoying when it comes to Hermione. HURRY UP AND ASK HER OUT BOY!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by Lix on Jul 5, 2004 23:13:21 GMT 11
lol theyre still young, the older they are when they get together the more liekly it is they'll stay together, but its going to be sooo cute
but hey in poa move she really hugs him when beaky gets killed.
|
|
talisha
Guildmember
Number One Rushton Supporter GO WANDIES!
Posts: 1,535
|
Post by talisha on Jul 6, 2004 0:32:09 GMT 11
Oh my Gawsh! Thats so obvious! I cant believe that never went through my mind! Ron was jealous of Harry for being rich and famous cause he thought Hermione might have liked him better! OMG so smart!
I love the bit in GoF and Hermione tells Ron to ask her out, not as a last resort next time.... its great cause he's so clueless but doesnt think that its obvious that he likes her... sigh* its great!
|
|
|
|
Post by Dameon on Jul 6, 2004 11:44:12 GMT 11
Harry's so on to them!
Poor Harry, it's so annoying when you have friends that behave like those two!!!
He's the one REALLY suffering!
KSL
|
|
talisha
Guildmember
Number One Rushton Supporter GO WANDIES!
Posts: 1,535
|
Post by talisha on Jul 6, 2004 21:18:19 GMT 11
Yeah, but I think Harry doesnt mind too bad. Just wants them to hurry up and get together!!! Thats what I'd be like anyway!
Come on Ron! Make your move!
|
|
|
|
Post by Lix on Jul 7, 2004 0:20:29 GMT 11
im going to vote krum for the fun of it
|
|
|
|
Post by Lix on Jul 7, 2004 0:21:42 GMT 11
has anyone noticed that the four founders of the english school didnt have english names? they had goderick, salazar, helga and rowena (which isnt too far off english i think) but the others are all european names
|
|
|
|
Post by Lix on Jul 7, 2004 0:22:23 GMT 11
eeek! sorry for spaming, but im afaird ill be misunderstood, i want ron and hermoine to get together, i was voting krum for the half blood prince
|
|
talisha
Guildmember
Number One Rushton Supporter GO WANDIES!
Posts: 1,535
|
Post by talisha on Jul 7, 2004 1:00:31 GMT 11
haha that's ok Elixa! I thought you were crazy for a while... thinking you wanted victor and hermione to be together instead....
I never considered Krum as the HBP... I s'pose that could be a possibility. Awww if it was HB Princess... couldda been Fleur, she is part Veela....
|
|
|
|
Post by Megana on Jul 7, 2004 11:08:55 GMT 11
But is Krum a half blood? I can't seem to remember if he was or not. I have a very bad memory.
And Ron and Hermoine are so cute! Ron's totally clueless, but still cute. Yes, that scene in the PoA movie when Hermoine huged Ron at Buckbeaks exicution! I was so sitting there going 'Awe, so sweet!' I wish those two would hurry up and get together.
Dumbledore and Sirius.....hmmm, Dumbledore has always taken Sirius's side, hasn't he? Dumbledore just has a funny way with words. I don't think that he ever truly believed that Sirius was guilty, he just wasn't entirely sure of the truth.
|
|
|
|
Post by Dameon on Jul 7, 2004 12:31:54 GMT 11
THANKYOU MEGANA!!!
Dumbeldore is NEVER wrong, so he couldn't have believed Sirius guilty!
KSL
|
|
talisha
Guildmember
Number One Rushton Supporter GO WANDIES!
Posts: 1,535
|
Post by talisha on Jul 7, 2004 14:58:46 GMT 11
Dumbeldore is NEVER wrong, so he couldn't have believed Sirius guilty!
Hhhhh hhhmmmmmm NEVER wrong? Did you read the 5th book??? (argh i hate that smiley) I dont know about Dumbledore always trusting Sirius... I think it likely, but I don't know... |
|
|
|
Post by Dameon on Jul 7, 2004 18:48:15 GMT 11
Yes, I did read it. I'm reading again right now
When is Dumbeldore wrong?
KSL
|
|
|
|
Post by Megana on Jul 10, 2004 10:44:27 GMT 11
Yeah, Talisha. I can't seem to remember Dumbledore ever being wrong. He always seems to have the inside scoop on everything. Dumbledore was one of the only people who believed Harry that Voldermort was back at the end of book 4, and all through book 5 until the stuff at the ministary happened. I think that he's definately been on Sirius' side the who time, even if he wasn't entirely sure of the truth.
|
|
Bobbi
Gypsy
d?rkdr?ams
Posts: 929
|
Post by Bobbi on Jul 10, 2004 20:57:47 GMT 11
*ahem* I have a theory. This theory I will explain to you very soon. Ahem. I am about to explain to you my theory. The next thing I will talk to you about will be my theory. My theory is the next thing that you will hear. I will explain my theory to you. Ahem. My theory. I have a theory. I am about to explain my theory to you. The next thing you will hear will be my theory. My theory is..ahem..my theory. I have a theory which I will explain to you very soon. The next thing you hear will in fact, be my theory. I have a theory which I will explain to you very soon. In fact, I will cut to the chase and tell you... I have a theory. This theory I will explain to you very soon. Ahem. I am about to explain to you my theory. The next thing I will talk to you about..... *screams as everyone comes out brandishing knives* OK!!! I'll tell you. The nex thing I will talk to you about will be my - ARGH!!! *ducks a flying knife* Ok. Here it is. Dumbledore is EVILYes, you may be wondering why. And sometimes, I do too. But you have to have faith in theories. Otherwise they are no longer theories. Right?...Right. Yes. So thats my theory. I dont know why. I did actually have a teeny weeny bit of evidence but this has turned out to be quite a long post for me so I cant be bothered to look it up and type it all out. But is doesnt really matter anyway - there really wasn't much evidence. But there IS some. Maybe one dya I'll look it up again. But anyway, the main reason I think he's evil is that I have a grudge against Dumbledore and it would be a GREAT twist. Hey what if Dumbledore is the halfblood prince? Nah, hes just evil. Ok ill leave you all now before I'm killed BYe!!!!! And yes, the "Dumbledore is EVIL" WAS meant to be small. I dont know why. I just wanted to see if it would work. I wonder what would happen if you wrote 0 there. Hmm. I have a new experiment to carry out!! bye!!!!  |
|
|
|
Post by Dameon on Jul 10, 2004 23:22:38 GMT 11
Bobbi, you be a very strange person
But we love you anyway
And no. Dumbledore is NOT evil. I certainly won't accept that without evidence, and I probably won't accept it at all.
What's your grudge? Do share!!!
KSL
|
|
|
|
Post by Trillium on Jul 11, 2004 2:17:23 GMT 11
Ithougt it (the HBP) was Hagrid when i first heard of it  But... I was thinking. Halfblood doesn't have to be confined to wizard/muggle, nor half giant. So, do Centaurs have royalty? because Firenze could be it... Or Draco Because Draco could be half Veela Actually, i read a fanfiction AGES ago, about a prince-dude in the Forbidden Forest... It sounsd kinda similar But it was Draco/Ginny, and i don't think JK's will do that for me ~Trill |
|
|
|
Post by Dameon on Jul 11, 2004 12:22:30 GMT 11
An interesting thought, but Draco can't be half Veela I'm afraid.
His mother is Sirius' cousin, Tonks' Aunt and Bellatrix Lestrange's sister.
KSL
PS. Hi Trillium, nice to meet thee!
|
|
|
|
Post by Trillium on Jul 11, 2004 16:13:05 GMT 11
Ah, truespoken. I didn't think of that.
~Trill
|
|
|
|
Post by Megana on Jul 11, 2004 19:25:51 GMT 11
On the topic of centaurs, I read ages ago while search for the title of book 6 and 7, that book 6 was gonna be called 'the mudblood's revolt', and that 7 was gonna be 'the quest of the centaur' or 'the centaur's quest' or something to do with centaurs. It had centaur in the title anyway. Obviously they're not the proper titles, but meh, it got me thinking.
|
|
Bobbi
Gypsy
d?rkdr?ams
Posts: 929
|
Post by Bobbi on Jul 11, 2004 22:22:58 GMT 11
Bobbi, you be a very strange person
But we love you anyway
And no. Dumbledore is NOT evil. I certainly won't accept that without evidence, and I probably won't accept it at all.
What's your grudge? Do share!!!
KSL well i dont know. i just thought it would be a good twist. and i was p!ssed off at him at the end of the last one coz he didnt tell harry all that stuff and...i dunno. there are just bits throughout it that are kind of out of character. maybe HES possesed. or thats not the real dumbledore. although shes already used that. hmm. be u a tarsin-for-shadowman person? if so, its like that theory. just lots of little things. ok i admit theres not alot of evidence. and that post really was quite stange. but i was tired and i DO think it would be an excellent twist! |
|
Elspethseeker
Guildmember
OH YEAH MOONFAIR SEASON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posts: 2,460
|
Post by Elspethseeker on Jul 12, 2004 13:39:53 GMT 11
HEllo! i am nack yay! Dumbledor was wrong in the sense that he never told harry about the prophecey and he even admits it he had gooodf intentions but is not perfect. Also he is not evil. You know i wonder who harry will end up with. ;D
|
|
talisha
Guildmember
Number One Rushton Supporter GO WANDIES!
Posts: 1,535
|
Post by talisha on Jul 12, 2004 21:45:44 GMT 11
wrong?
I seem to recall him admitting he was wrong. Not telling Harry about the Prophecy and trying to hide things from him.
hehe just read what elfseeker wrote, I'm in agreeing with her.
Dumbledore isn't always right! He makes mistakes like everyone else.
|
|
|
|
Post by Dameon on Jul 12, 2004 22:34:19 GMT 11
But he's always right about PEOPLE!!!
I mean, he trusts people, and if he trusts them they turn out to be trustworthy. People he doesn't trust (and he was always suspicious of Tom Riddle) turn out to be bad.
Therefore: He could never have distrusted Sirius, because Sirius WAS good.
That's what I mean. Does it make sense?
KSL
|
|
